Illustrated cover reading "Instructional Design Models Compared: ADDIE, SAM, Action Mapping and 7 More" on a butter yellow background with a dots pattern

Instructional Design Models Compared: ADDIE, SAM, Action Mapping and 7 More

Table of Contents

Share:
Easily share intel
Summarise this page with your favorite AI assistant

Instructional design models are step-by-step methods for planning, building and checking a course. The right one depends on your project. ADDIE suits fixed, audited work, SAM suits content that keeps changing, and Action Mapping suits behavior change. This guide compares ten models and gives you two tables to pick one by situation.

Most guides list models and stop there. They rarely say which to use on Monday morning. We read the published descriptions of all ten models, then built a choose-by-situation table and a worked comparison on one sample project. Both are our judgment, not research.

Key takeaways

  • None of the sources we read compares learning results across models, so any claim that one model is “best” is opinion.
  • ADDIE, SAM, Dick and Carey, Kemp and ASSURE run the project. Gagné, Merrill, Backward Design and 4C/ID shape the learning inside it. Action Mapping sits between the two.
  • Pick by your tightest constraint: how stable the content is, how often real reviewers can respond, and how costly an error is.
  • Pairing one process model with one lesson framework is normal and works well.

What are instructional design models, and does the choice matter?

Instructional design models are structured methods for turning a training need into a finished course. Some set the order of project work. Others set how a lesson is built. The choice matters less than most lists suggest, but it does affect speed, review cycles and how much rework you face.

An ATD blog post, “Ask a Trainer: ADDIE Versus SAM” (January 2020), calls both models project management models. Its author says three questions matter more than the model. Is training the right fix? Is the course designed for how people learn? Is it designed for what people need to do?

We found no study in the pages we read that tests one model against another. New to the field? Start with our guide to instructional design basics for subject-matter-expert trainers, then come back here to choose a method.

How do the 10 instructional design models compare at a glance?

Ten models cover most corporate and classroom projects. ADDIE, SAM, Dick and Carey, Kemp and ASSURE are process models. Action Mapping starts from a business goal. Gagné, Merrill, Backward Design and 4C/ID guide how the learning itself is built. The table below shows each model’s core idea and its originator where a source states one.

Model Core idea Originator and date (as sources state)
ADDIE Five phases: analysis, design, development, implementation, evaluation No single originator (see below)
SAM Preparation, then loops of design and development with early prototypes Michael Allen, Allen Interactions
Action Mapping Start with a measurable goal and the actions people must take Cathy Moore
Gagné’s nine events Nine steps inside one lesson, from attention to transfer Robert Gagné, 1965
Merrill’s principles Five principles built around real problems Merrill, 2002 and 2007
Dick and Carey Ten steps from goals to summative evaluation Walter Dick and Lou Carey, 1978
Kemp Nine elements in a continuous cycle of revision Kemp, 1985; later editions with Morrison, Ross and Kalman
ASSURE Six steps for planning a lesson with media Not stated in the page we read
Backward Design Results first, then evidence, then learning plan Grant Wiggins and Jay McTighe, 1998
4C/ID Learning tasks, supportive information, just-in-time information, part-task practice Jeroen van Merriënboer

How do ADDIE and SAM differ, and where did ADDIE come from?

ADDIE finishes each phase before the next one starts. SAM works in short loops of design, prototype and review. ADDIE gives clear sign-off points and a paper trail. SAM surfaces problems early, but it needs reviewers who will react to rough work.

Many guides say ADDIE was built at Florida State University for the U.S. military. In a 2003 article, Michael Molenda searched for ADDIE’s origin and found no primary source. He calls it an umbrella term for a family of models with a shared structure. He also reports that the mid-1970s military procedures built with Florida State used different headings and were not called ADDIE. Treat the five phases as common practice, not one official model.

Michael Allen created SAM. On the Allen Interactions SAM page, it has three phases: Preparation, Iterative Design and Iterative Development. Design starts with the Savvy Start, a one- to two-day workshop. Development moves through Alpha, Beta and Gold versions. These are the vendor’s own claims, and we have not tested them.

In our judgment, choose ADDIE when sign-offs and records matter most. Choose SAM when the content will change and reviewers can respond every few days.

What do Action Mapping, Dick and Carey, Kemp and ASSURE add?

Action Mapping asks whether training is needed at all. Dick and Carey, Kemp and ASSURE are older process models built around objectives and evaluation. Dick and Carey is the most formal, Kemp the most flexible, and ASSURE the most classroom-focused.

Action Mapping. Cathy Moore’s workflow starts with a goal tied to a measure that will change. You then list the observable actions people must take and find what blocks them. Training is only one possible fix. If practice is needed, you prototype one activity first. It pairs well with scenario-based learning for soft skills.

Dick and Carey. Walter Dick and Lou Carey first published their model in 1978. Its ten steps run from instructional goals to summative evaluation, and it treats instruction as a system. Each objective states a behavior, a condition and a degree, so it suits courses that must be measured. Our guide to how to write learning objectives shows that format in practice.

Kemp. An open instructional design handbook describes four core components (students, objectives, methods and evaluation) and nine design elements. The elements are linked, can be worked in any order, and are revised in a continuous cycle.

ASSURE. One university page presents ASSURE as a six-step lesson planning process: analyze learners, state objectives, select methods and media, utilize them, require learner participation, and evaluate and revise. It is strong on media choice and learner activity, and lighter on whether training is the right fix.

What do Gagné, Merrill, Backward Design and 4C/ID add?

These four shape the learning, not the project schedule. Gagné lists nine events inside a lesson. Merrill centers instruction on real problems. Backward Design starts from the evidence of success. 4C/ID builds whole-task practice for complex skills. Pair any of them with a process model.

Gagné’s nine events. According to Northern Illinois University’s guide, Robert Gagné proposed them in 1965. They run from gaining attention and sharing objectives to practice, feedback, assessment, and retention and transfer. In our judgment, the events map neatly onto a screen sequence.

Merrill’s principles. Merrill names five: problem-centered, activation, demonstration, application and integration. He reports that they came from comparing several instructional theories and finding shared principles with no contradictions.

Backward Design. Wiggins and McTighe’s 1998 book Understanding by Design sets three stages. You identify desired results, decide what evidence will show them, then plan the learning. It suits inherited slide decks, where you must decide what to cut.

4C/ID. Jeroen van Merriënboer’s model has four components: learning tasks, supportive information, just-in-time information and part-task practice. It targets complex cognitive skills, with support that fades as learners improve. One training vendor’s summary calls it a poor fit for simple recall or for quick, low-budget delivery.

Pro tip: Stack One Process Model and One Lesson Framework. Pick one model to run the project and one to shape each lesson, such as SAM plus Gagné or ADDIE plus Merrill. Write both on page one of the project brief, so reviewers know what to expect.

Which instructional design models fit which situation?

Match the model to your tightest constraint. If content is stable and sign-offs matter, start with ADDIE or Dick and Carey. If content changes, start with SAM. If the problem is behavior, start with Action Mapping. The table below maps seven common situations to a starting model and an add-on.

Situation Start with Add Why (our judgment)
Annual compliance refresher, stable rules, audit trail needed ADDIE Gagné Phases leave sign-off records. Events give a repeatable lesson shape.
Manager soft-skills course judged on job behavior Action Mapping Merrill It starts from the behavior and turns problems into practice.
Software training while the product keeps changing SAM Gagné Short loops absorb change before you build everything.
Technician troubleshooting or another complex skill 4C/ID ADDIE Whole-task practice, with ADDIE to schedule the build.
Rebuilding an old slide-based course Backward Design SAM Define what learners must prove, then prototype.
Large formal curriculum with many courses Dick and Carey Backward Design A systems view keeps courses consistent.
One subject-matter expert building a first course alone ASSURE Gagné Six short steps plus a lesson skeleton.

If an expert is building the course, our course development process for small training teams shows where review gates belong, whichever model you choose.

Pro tip: Rank Your Three Constraints. Before choosing, rank content stability, reviewer availability and cost of error from tightest to loosest. The tightest one names your process model. This is our rule of thumb, not research.

How would each model handle the same project?

Take one project: a 20-minute course that teaches new managers to give feedback. Each model starts in a different place. The table shows the first move under each. This is an illustration we built, not a case study, and the risks are our judgment.

Model First move Risk if used alone
ADDIE Analyze the audience and the performance gap Slow proof that the course works
SAM Hold a Savvy Start workshop Scope drift without firm goals
Action Mapping Set a measurable goal for feedback quality Needs people who know the real job
Gagné Plan the nine events across 20 minutes Silent on whether training is needed
Merrill Choose one real feedback problem Needs realistic cases from experts
Dick and Carey Write the goal and analyze the skills Heavy paperwork for 20 minutes
Kemp Start with the learner profile Loops without a finish line
ASSURE Analyze the manager group Light on the training-or-not question
Backward Design Define a good feedback conversation Needs clear performance criteria
4C/ID Split feedback into whole tasks of rising difficulty Over-built for a short course

Action Mapping and Backward Design both begin with proof of success. SAM and Kemp both allow loops. That overlap is why mixing models works.

What should you do next?

Rank your three constraints and pick a starting model from the situation table. Then write your learning objectives, because every model here depends on them. Our guide to writing learning objectives gives you a formula and examples.

When you reach screen-level design, a storyboard keeps experts and reviewers aligned. Our eLearning storyboard template guide shows the fields to use, whichever model you picked.

When you are ready to build, you can start free on SimpliAuthor. SimpliAuthor is made by SimpliTrain, the same company that publishes this site, so weigh this suggestion accordingly. As of November 2026, its home page says AI can draft objectives, outlines and assessments from your documents for you to edit. It also says courses publish as SCORM 1.2 or 2004. The page does not list what the free sign-up includes, and we have not tested the tool.

Frequently asked questions

What are the main instructional design models?

The most cited are ADDIE, SAM, Action Mapping, Gagné’s nine events, Merrill’s principles, Dick and Carey, Kemp, ASSURE, Backward Design and 4C/ID. ADDIE, SAM, Dick and Carey, Kemp and ASSURE mostly describe how to run a project. Gagné, Merrill, Backward Design and 4C/ID mostly shape the learning itself.

What is the most popular instructional design model?

ADDIE is the one most guides name first. An ATD blog post says ATD research finds it the most widely used. Popularity is not proof it works better. A model that suits a large compliance rollout can slow a small team down, so choose by your project’s size, risk, deadline and how much your subject-matter experts can review.

What has replaced ADDIE?

Nothing has fully replaced it. SAM and Action Mapping are common alternatives, and many teams blend them with ADDIE. Molenda’s 2003 article calls ADDIE an umbrella term for a family of models, which explains why it adapts so easily.

Which instructional design model is best for eLearning?

No single model wins. For a stable course with sign-offs, ADDIE works. For fast-changing content, SAM works. For behavior change, start with Action Mapping. For the screens themselves, Gagné’s events or Merrill’s principles give a ready structure. Most real projects pair two models, so match each one to a different job.

Can you combine instructional design models?

Yes, and it is common. A typical pairing uses one process model to run the project, such as ADDIE or SAM, and one lesson framework, such as Gagné or Merrill. Choose the pair early and write it in the project plan, so reviewers know which decisions belong to the process and which belong to the individual lesson.

Is Bloom’s taxonomy an instructional design model?

Not really. It sorts learning goals by level of thinking. It was published in 1956 and revised in 2001 by Anderson and Krathwohl. Designers use it to write objectives, then use a model such as ADDIE to plan the work. Our learning objectives guide covers the verbs.

Want to learn more?

Reach out to us to learn more.

One Platform for
All Your Training Needs

Get a personalized demo.