Illustrated cover reading "Adult Learning Principles: Applying Knowles' Six Principles in eLearning" on a mint green background with a mosaic pattern

Adult Learning Principles: Applying Knowles’ Six Principles in eLearning

Table of Contents

Share:
Easily share intel
Summarise this page with your favorite AI assistant

Adult learning principles are assumptions about how working adults approach training. They want a reason to learn, some control and respect for what they know. They also want a real need, practical problems to solve and goals of their own. Malcolm Knowles wrote the best-known set, and this post turns his six into design moves you can put on an eLearning screen.

It also covers what most guides skip. Researchers still argue about whether andragogy, Knowles’ approach to helping adults learn, is a theory at all. The evidence that it improves results is thin. So we treat the principles as useful prompts, not laws, and we mark where they break.

This guide is for instructional designers, trainers and subject-matter experts who build courses for employees or clients. You will get a table of design moves, a rewritten course opening, and a short list of cases where the principles do not fit.

Key takeaways

  • Knowles described six assumptions: need to know, self-concept, experience, readiness, orientation and motivation. He described them as assumptions, not as a finished theory.
  • The evidence is mixed. One review called the research on andragogy inconclusive, and critics say children share many of these traits.
  • Each principle can become one visible move on a screen, such as a reason on screen one or a question about the learner’s own experience.
  • Self-direction works best when learners already know the topic. Beginners need more guidance, so check prior knowledge before you offer choices.

What are the six adult learning principles Knowles described?

Knowles described six assumptions about adult learners. Adults need to know why they should learn something. They see themselves as self-directed. Their experience is a learning resource. They become ready to learn when a work or life role demands it. They want to solve problems. And they are driven mostly from within.

Knowles treated these as assumptions, and the set grew over time. A summary of his 1984 work in the encyclopedia of informal education lists five and says internal motivation was added later. A 2010 review by Sang Chan lists six by adding the need to know. So when one guide lists four principles and another lists six, they are counting different versions of the same model.

The word andragogy is older than Knowles. Chan says Alexander Kapp coined it in 1833. Treat the six as questions to ask about your own learners, not as facts about every adult. If your authors are subject-matter experts who are new to design, start with instructional design basics for SMEs.

Do adult learning principles have evidence behind them?

Only partly. Researchers still debate whether andragogy is a theory, a model or a set of guidelines. John Rachal described the research on whether it works as inconclusive. Treat the principles as reasonable design prompts that you test with your own learners, not as proven rules.

The critiques are specific. The same encyclopedia entry reports that Hartree (1984) asked whether andragogy describes learning or teaching. Other critics argue that children also show self-direction and use their experience, so the line between adult and child learning is blurry. The entry’s author, M. K. Smith, also argues that the idea of self-direction is culturally bound and rooted in largely North American thinking.

In his 2002 critique in Adult Education Quarterly, Rachal adds that researchers define andragogy in different ways, which makes their results hard to compare. Cindy Nebel of The Learning Scientists reaches a similar place from cognitive science. In her 2022 post on pedagogy and andragogy, she finds Knowles’ descriptions of adults largely accurate. She argues the same principles apply at every age. She says the real differences are less about age than about choice and prior knowledge. Adults who are new to a subject learn much like children.

What does this mean for a course builder? Most of the moves below cost little, so trying them is reasonable. But measure the result with your own completion and quiz data instead of assuming a gain.

How do you apply adult learning principles on an eLearning screen?

Give each principle one visible job on the screen. State the reason up front, offer real choices and ask for the learner’s experience. Tie content to a current task, build practice around problems and show progress toward a personal goal. The table pairs each principle with a move and an example.

Principle Design move Screen-level example
Need to know: adults want the reason first Open with the task the learner will do better, the cost of skipping it and the time it takes. Put content second. Screen 1 reads: “After this module you can approve a purchase order and spot the errors that cause rejections. About 10 minutes.”
Self-concept: adults see themselves as self-directed Offer choices that change the path, not decorations. Let people test out of what they know. A “Show me I already know this” button opens three questions. Passing them skips to the practice screen.
Experience: prior experience is a resource Ask before you tell. Use the learner’s answer as the hook for the lesson. A text box asks, “What do you check first when a customer disputes an invoice?” The next screen compares answers with the standard steps.
Readiness: a role or task creates the need Release content when the task is near. Break it into short pieces tagged by role. A “Before your first audit” module is assigned the week the audit is scheduled, with a one-screen refresher linked from the checklist.
Orientation: adults prefer problem-centered learning Name modules after problems, not topics. Make the first interaction a decision. The module title is “A customer says the invoice is wrong,” and the first screen is a scenario with three possible replies.
Motivation: drive comes mostly from within Show growing competence and link to the learner’s own goal. Keep points and badges as extras. A progress panel reads, “You can now handle 3 of 5 common billing disputes,” instead of a point total.

The six assumptions come from the sources above. The design moves and examples are our judgment, not tested results. The first move depends on clear objectives, so see how to write learning objectives. For checks across a whole course, use eLearning course design best practices.

Pro tip: Test Screen One on a Real Learner. Show only the opening screen to one person from your target group and ask what they will be able to do afterward. If they cannot say it in their own words, the need-to-know move has not landed, and no later screen will fix that.

What does a course opening look like when it follows the principles?

It starts with a task, not a topic. In the example below, a policy overview becomes a short opening. It states the task, offers a skip-ahead check, asks for the learner’s experience and moves into a problem. The example is invented to show the moves. It is not taken from a real course.

The course teaches managers new expense-approval rules. Here is the opening as many courses build it:

  • Screen 1: “Welcome to Expense Policy Training.”
  • Screen 2: “Purpose and scope of the policy.”
  • Screen 3: “Definitions.”
  • Screens 4 to 20: more rules, then a first quiz.

Here is the same opening rewritten with the six principles:

  • Screen 1: “You approve expense reports. This 12-minute module covers the three situations where approvals go wrong.” (need to know)
  • Screen 2: “Already know the approval steps? Answer three questions to skip ahead.” (self-concept)
  • Screen 3: “Think of the last report you approved. What did you check first?” Then the standard checklist appears beside the learner’s answer. (experience)
  • Screen 4: A scenario. “A taxi receipt has no date. What do you do?” Feedback explains the rule, and definitions open only when needed. (readiness and orientation)
  • Screen 5: A progress line shows which of the three situations the learner has handled. (motivation)

The rewrite is not longer. It moves the rules behind a decision the learner cares about. For a deeper look at scenario design, see scenario-based learning for soft skills.

When do adult learning principles not apply?

They weaken when learners are beginners, when the rule is fixed, when the setting discourages self-direction, or when you assume age predicts behavior. Self-direction works best when learners already know enough to steer. New topics need more explicit guidance first.

Situation Where the principle breaks What to do instead
Beginners on a new topic Self-direction and discovery can overload working memory. Kirschner, Sweller and Clark (2006) argue minimal guidance is less effective for novices. Give worked examples and guided steps first. Add choice as skill grows.
Experts with strong habits Experience can be outdated or wrong, and asking for it only invites defense of old habits. Surface the habit, then correct it with a clear case. Judgment, not research.
Mandatory training Readiness and motivation are weak when learners did not choose the course. Nebel notes that adults often do not choose required training. Say plainly why it is required, keep it short and offer test-out.
Cultures and settings that favor structure M. K. Smith argues the idea of self-direction is culturally bound, so open choice may not fit every group. Ask a local reviewer to check tone, choice and feedback before you ship.

Age is a weak guide. Nebel’s argument is that prior knowledge and choice matter more than birthdays, so build learner profiles from role and skill level, not age.

Pro tip: Add a Pre-Check Before You Add Choices. A three-question pre-check tells you which path a learner needs. Send those who miss it to guided steps and those who pass it to practice. Kirschner and colleagues describe the expertise reversal effect, where support that helps beginners becomes extra load for people who already know the topic.

What should you do next?

Pick one live course and read its first three screens against the table. Rewrite screen one so it states the task, the time and the payoff. Add one question about the learner’s experience and one decision before the first block of rules. Then compare completion and quiz results with the old version.

Keep the process separate from the principles. Models such as ADDIE and SAM tell you how to run the project, and our instructional design models compared post helps you pick one. The adult learning principles tell you what the learner needs from each screen.

If you build in SimpliAuthor, you can start free. SimpliAuthor is made by SimpliTrain, the same company that publishes this site, so weigh this suggestion accordingly. Based on its published product pages as of November 2026, the AI can draft objectives, an outline and assessments from your documents. The course arrives as editable blocks you can rework with the moves above. We have not tested it.

Frequently asked questions

How many adult learning principles are there?

It depends on the source. Knowles’ own model has five or six assumptions, depending on the version. Other guides list eight or ten principles by adding ideas such as learning by doing and repetition. The numbers differ because authors count and group the ideas differently, not because adults changed.

What is the difference between andragogy and pedagogy?

Knowles contrasted andragogy, his model for adults, with pedagogy, which he tied to teaching children. By 1984 he had softened that split. Some critics, including Clark Quinn, call it a false dichotomy because good design for any learner should reflect how brains work, not age.

Do adults learn differently from children?

Less than the principles suggest. Cindy Nebel argues the same principles apply at every age, and that prior knowledge and choice matter more than age. Adults new to a subject learn much like children do. The differences that remain are mostly about experience, motivation and how much control the learner has.

Who created adult learning theory?

Alexander Kapp coined the term andragogy in 1833, according to Chan (2010). Malcolm Knowles brought it to the American education scene in 1968. He later wrote The Modern Practice of Adult Education (1970) and The Adult Learner (1973). Other thinkers have added their own adult learning theories since.

Do adult learning principles apply to mandatory compliance training?

Yes, with limits. Readiness and motivation are weaker when learners had no choice. Say why the course is required, state the task they will do better, let people test out of what they know, and use realistic scenarios. Keep the rules behind a decision the learner cares about.

Want to learn more?

Reach out to us to learn more.

One Platform for
All Your Training Needs

Get a personalized demo.